Monthly Archives: November 2024

Stifel flash note: SEYE KO’d by Seeing Machines?

Posted on by
Reply

In a flash note published yesterday, Stifel confirmed that Smart Eye’s Q3 results clearly show it is taking at beating at the hands of the global leader Seeing Machines.

Stifel analyst Peter McNally confirmed what well researched investors already know; that the auto industry is in a tough place, particularly for Smart Eye. Regarding Smart Eye, he commented: “Automotive revenue shows a slight dip (-1.5% q/q) to SEK 32.4m and is therefore similar to last quarter, which was flattish also. Part of the reason for being flattish is a transition away from services (NRE) to licences, which grew 100% y/y to an undisclosed amount.”

For those who still think Smart Eye is a contender for the automotive crown, McNally’s killer punch is that: “On a like-for-like basis, Seeing Machines Automotive revenue (excluding Aerospace) in FY24 was well over $60m versus Smart Eye’s $11.4m (Q323- Q224), so it still looks like Seeing Machines is well ahead.”

According to McNally, two more take-aways from the results were, firstly: “Commentary on growth in Automotive licences is positive saying the growth rate should increase in Q4 and ‘even higher growth in 2025.’ Clearly this suggests that they see adoption is increasing, which is good news for the industry, but we still think they are playing catch up at this stage as their revenues are significantly lower.”

Secondly, “Smart Eye is also suggesting that volumes will pick up in Q4 in Aftermarket, which somewhat agrees with Seeing Machines’ expectation of a ramp in volumes in its fiscal H225 (Jan-Jun 2025).”

Having listened to the Smart Eye presentation, I found the reluctance of the company to state the number of cars on the road with its technology a telling indication that it has been bested in autos by Seeing Machines. Smart Eye once used to boast of having 1m cars on the road but, as Seeing Machines approaches 3m by the end of this calendar year, the Swedish company has yet to announce hitting 2m, preferring to use the opaque terms ‘design wins’ and ‘models’.

Of course, do your own research.

The writer holds stock in Seeing Machines.

Euro NCAP pushes for quality DMS, as provided by Seeing Machines

Posted on by
Reply

Following the publication of the 2026 Euro NCAP safety protocols, Seeing Machines is on the cusp of a significant re-rate as OEMs and Tier 1s race to meet higher performance requirements for driver/occupant monitoring.

The two documents can be viewed here, courtesy of Colin Barnden, Principal Analyst at Semicast Research: 

The significance of these documents appear to have passed many investors by. However, no less a figure than Richard Schram, Technical Director at Euro NCAP, has confirmed to me that from January 1st, 2026 a new passenger car will not achieve a 5 star Euro NCAP safety rating in Europe unless it has a driver/occupant monitoring system that meets the criteria specified in these 2026 protocols.

The implications of this news are huge for any OEM wishing to sell new passenger cars models in Europe. This is because, even though driver monitoring is mandatory in Europe from July 2026, Euro NCAP is effectively “pushing for higher performance than the regulation does”, according to Schram.

This is great news for Seeing Machines as, being the most technically proficient provider of DMS/OMS with a fast to implement rearview mirror system, it offers the most realistic solution for many OEMs in that timeframe whose premium models will certainly require 5 star safety. [Elon Musk are you listening?]

I’m therefore anticipating a raft of extensions to existing contracts as well as new contracts to secure its services via Magna, but also via its other partners over the next 6 months.

I think that in the short term there will be such demand for its technology that its average selling price (ASP) will not drop significantly even as volumes expand. Moreover, that ASP is, I believe, already at a significant premium to its competitors. 

The upshot is that within the next 6 months, as SEE speeds towards 4m cars on the road with its technology, SEYE will be left in the dust, alongside Tobii and Cipia – which must be feeling the pain from the economic collapse of Israel.

Seeing Machines itself has previously stated that it expects to take around 40 per cent of the global passenger car market for DMS by volume, 50 per cent by value. I’ve long held the view that 75 per cent by value is possible and I think this news from Euro NCAP confirms that there was a sound reason for my holding onto this stock, despite experiencing a roller-coaster ride.

As OEMs, Tier 1s and fund managers realise the implications of this news I expect increased buying of SEE stock as it brushes off misplaced investor concerns. This should push the price up significantly. 

Call me paranoid but over the next 6-8 months I believe private investors should beware market makers shaking the tree in order to acquire their shares cheaply for institutional buyers.

Of course, do your own research as this is only my opinion. Maybe my prediction of a 75 per cent market share of the global DMS market 8 years ago was a fluke.

The writer holds stock in Seeing Machines.

Seeing Machines drives towards cashflow breakeven 

Posted on by
Reply

Despite well publicised woes in the auto industry, Seeing Machines penetration of the auto market continues apace with the latest quarterly KPIs showing that it is on track to pass 3m cars on the road for this calendar year, as predicted by Safestocks back in May. 

The Q1 FY2025 auto figures showed quarterly production of 405,669 units, taking the number of cars on the road with Seeing Machines’ technology to 2,617,091.

That represents 100 per cent growth year-on-year, which sets it apart from all its rivals – none of which has even hit 2m cars on the road.

In a note published today by house analyst Stifel, analyst Peter McNally wrote: “Reassuringly, the company’s 8th Automotive production programme has commenced, which adds another since the 7th was announced at the Q424 KPIs in August (6th at the end of FY23). Although Automotive industry volumes are light, more of the company’s OEM customers are launching, meaning adoption/ royalties should continue to rise further. We think two more are likely in 2025 and additional programmes are launching within individual OEMs providing a compound effect.”

He added: “We think it can probably add another 1.9m cars on the road in FY25E (vs 1.1m in FY24) with only mild decreases in average selling price.”

In a separate interview with Proactive Investors today, Seeing Machines CEO Paul McGlone confirmed that 2 more auto programmes are due to be launched this financial year.

Guardian

McGlone also explained that Guardian Gen 3 sales would be ramping up in the second half. Given that average recurring revenue for Aftermaket driver monitoring (excluding any effect from Caterpillar) rose 13 per cent over Q1 2024, the improved gross margin from Gen 3 hardware sales should underpin an even better performance over the remainder of this financial year.

Indeed, in that same interview CFO Martin Ive again confirmed that the company is determined to hit cashflow breakeven on a monthly basis by the end of this financial year. 

Undervalued

Certainly, the company’s share price has recently been hit by concerns over cash, however McNally’s view on this is: “
we believe 3rd party development costs will reduce in addition to headcount, and cash should benefit from growth in higher margin OEM Royalties (c.100% GM) and a Guardian Gen 3 ramp in H225. We think the company has a portfolio of non-dilutive additional cash options if needed, as history suggests.”

McNally adds: “Following the recent share price decline, the shares trade at 3.1x EV/Sales, which we think is attractive for a market leader in a large industry with a 3-year forecast revenue CAGR of 23% or 42% for gross profit through FY27E. Buy.” 

Personally, I’m expecting further auto OEMs wins, license deals and a ramp in Gen 3 Guardian sales in the second half to raise the share price significantly as this financial year progresses. Furthermore, many funds are watching this stock from the sidelines and profitability is the key catalyst that I believe will see them buy in.

In my experience, nervous private investors tend to move out of a stock just when they should be buying more or at the very least holding. Mr Market hasn’t done years of research in this stock and is driven by fear and greed. Of course, do your own research.

The writer holds stock in Seeing Machines

Auto industry woes affect Seeing Machines

Posted on by
Reply

While Seeing Machines’ FY24 results illustrated a year of significant progress, auto industry headwinds and a slower than expected ramp in Guardian Gen 3 sales have led to Stifel reducing its revenue estimates for FY25-26. This in turn has led to it reducing its DCF-based target price to 11.4p from 13p.

It’s certainly disappointing news for shareholders but Peter McNally, analyst at Stifel, commented in a detailed note issued on October 31st: “Despite delays we maintain our positive stance on the shares moderating our target price to 11.4p (13.0p) and see the company extending its leadership with proven implementation and deployment into an increasingly regulated market.”

Revenues for 2025 are now predicted to be US$73.1m with a pre-tax loss of $13.3m, while in 2026 revenues of $97.5m produced a pre-tax profit of $5m.

Material uncertainty

In the full Annual Report (on page 46), the auditor PWC also made a comment about ‘material uncertainty’, reflecting the cash outflow of $11.9m in the FY24 results. Personally, I believe they are only fulfilling their obligations to warn investors about potential risks (while also covering themselves), yet it is unsettling for green investors unused to the conservative ways of auditors.

Stifel’s McNally certainly didn’t appear unduly concerned, stating: “We note the auditor’s “material uncertainty” comment but see a path to breakeven given strong (although reduced) operational drivers and cash costs containment”.

He went on to explain his estimate changes and assumptions in detail: “We reduce FY25/26E revenue by 11%/17% assuming a slightly higher GM% of 64% (62%), driven by a slightly higher software mix resulting in a cash EBITDA loss of $14.9m ($10.8m) for FY25E but profit of $8.6m ($19.5m) in FY26E. This is based on stable cash opex of $65m, resulting in $9.8m cash at FY25E year-end and cash generation thereafter as royalties continue to ramp and Guardian Gen 3 volumes increase.”

In his presentation today on Investor Meet, Paul McGlone reiterated that the company still expects to hit breakeven on a monthly basis in Q4 of this financial year.

He went to explain that if additional working capital is required due to the lumpy nature of automotive revenues: “We have a reasonably simple solution in the form of receivables funding and that process is underway. We expect it to deliver additional working capital in the range of $5-10m.”

Furthermore, he added: “To the extent that we need additional cash, we have a whole range of opportunities before us, some of which are well progressed and are consistent with the types of programmes or results that we’ve delivered in the last 2-3 years.”

I assume here that he is referring to license deals which, as Stifel points out have had a dramatic effect on profitability and cash given its similar 100% gross margin nature to royalties. McNally teased in his note: “Licensing is very difficult to predict but the company has benefitted from licensing deals over the past few years from Magna for $5.4m in October 2022, Collins Aerospace for $10.0m in May 2023, and most recently Caterpillar for $16.5m in June 2024.”

I’m therefore fairly confident Paul McGlone and his team will pull another rabbit out of the bag this year. Happily, it seems smarter people that me are thinking the same.

Speaking directly about the cash concerns McNally wrote: “With $23.4m of cash on the balance sheet we feel that the company has sufficient cash for the year with the goal of reaching run-rate cash flow break even by the end of FY25E (June). The company also has a history of sourcing strategic funding and software license agreements that have benefited cash. We believe these options still exist and can provide additional cash if required.”

Peel Hunt

In a short note issued today Peel Hunt reiterated its ‘BUY’ rating but reduced its target price to 7p from 9p. Analyst Oliver Tipping stated:

“Management has re-affirmed its commitment to reach a cash break-even run rate in FY25. However, we believe this could be challenging. 

“Ultimately,  OEMs  across  the  industry  have  been  struggling  and  they dictate the speed of production. We fear timelines could shift to the right. 

“Seeing Machines’ ability to reach its break-even  run  rate  goal  is  likely  to hinge on its ability to control costs. Competitors, like Tobii, have already begun severe  spending  cuts  and we  believe  Seeing  Machines  will  require similar measures given  its  current  cash  burn  rate of $2m a month. To account for wider industry weakness, we reduce our TP from 9p to 7p.”

Reasons to be cheerful

While the share price tanked on Thursday, as nervous private investors do what they usually do when real life intervenes; panic and sell low, there are reasons to be cheerful.

In the Investor Meet presentation today Seeing Machines did confirm that for this financial year it expects: 

  1. 1.9 – 2.1 million annual production units for Automotive, contributing to high-margin royalty revenue. 
  2. A 20% increase in connected Guardian units generating monthly services revenue. 
  3. 13,000 – 15,000 Guardian Gen 3 units to be sold, predominantly in Q2 at a much higher margin (50%) than previously with Gen 2 units (10%). 
  4. Aviation to achieve Blue Label (functioning prototype) product delivery, adaptable for certain fields of use (simulator, air traffic control). 
  5. Cash flow break-even run rate target at end of FY2025.

In addition, during the Investor Meet presentation CEO Paul McGlone revealed that there has been a resurgence in the inflow of RFIs and RFQs for the auto industry. “We are currently processing RFQs for OEMS based in Japan, Korea, Europe, China and North America. The vehicles associated with those RFQs are largely for Europe, Japan and North America and would have start of production timing between 2027 and 2029. And we expect the sourcing of these programmes to begin in 2025 calendar year.”

Thus, I think Peel Hunt’s fears of auto timelines shifting to the right are unfounded. Indeed, Seeing Machines has already suffered from that and the market is now hot for DMS/OMS once more.

Amazing news?

Regarding Gen 3 sales, I’m also hearing a whisper that Seeing Machines has begun trials with a global US online retailer, which is A household name. If they are successful and a deal is announced a few months from now I’m pretty confident the share price will soar on that news alone. Can you guess the name?

I’ve been in this stock a long time, too long in truth. However, I’ve no intention of selling out when the company is so close to achieving breakeven. That’s because I believe it will trigger a bidding war. Do your own research of course.

The writer holds stock in Seeing Machines.

P.S. If anyone does make any money from this information do please consider making a small donation to a charity for the people in Gaza. As we worry about money they are being murdered en masse and ethnically cleansed, which according to international law constitutes genocide. Thanks.